Most people think of stress as something bad. It causes burnout. It creates anxiety. It interferes with our ability to focus, be productive, or even sleep. Check out most of the articles on stress and you will see headlines such as “Stress: The Number One Killer”, “4 Way Stress Is Destroying Your Body” and “How Stress Is Killing Your Libido”.
But not all stress is bad.
There’s another type of stress—good stress—that we don’t talk about as often. This can motivate us, give us energy, increase our sense of purpose, and even help us stay focused.
As leaders, we can help our teams recognize that stress is not always harmful. In fact, learning how to navigate it—rather than avoid it—is one of the most powerful ways to build resilience and protect well-being.
The Biology of Stress: It’s Not Just Fight or Flight
Most of us are familiar with the body’s “fight-or-flight” response. It’s the survival mechanism that kicks in when we feel threatened. The brain releases adrenaline and cortisol. Our heart rate spikes. We breathe faster. Muscles tighten. The body prepares to either run away or fight off a threat.
But the fight-or-flight response is only one of several biological stress responses.
Additional research is helping us to further understand our response and we are learning that there is so much more that we have access to. Fight and Flight is not outdated. It serves a purpose, but as leaders, there are other reactions that can be just as important—especially in a workplace context:
- The Challenge Response – which helps us rise to a demanding situation with focus and energy.
- The Tend and Befriend Response – which encourages connection and caregiving in the face of stress.
When people feel supported and purposeful, their response often shifts into one of these more positive and productive modes.
Good Stress vs. Bad Stress
Our teams are facing multiple stressors, from deadlines and more tasks to do than there is time, to personality conflicts and mental health challenges, and difficulties balancing personal lives. But most of these stressors are not threats to our life and do not necessitate our Fight and Flight response. Fight and Flight should only be activated in an emergency situation, like the fire alarms going off or the car in front suddenly coming to a dead stop. These other issues require a different response.
Our stress response is simply our body’s reaction to circumstances in which it feels it needs more strength, stamina, and alertness in order to survive, thrive and return our body’s physiological and psychological systems back to normal functioning. Our stress response gives us the power to tackle challenges and come out on top.
But like any power, it can be harnessed for productive ends or mishandled in ways that have destructive results. The amount of stress we feel given a certain set of circumstances is directly proportional to the degree in which we feel our skills and resources are adequate in addressing them. Far too often our interpretation of events around us involve inadequacy, personalization, and anger. When we see these issues in this way, we inappropriately invoke the Fight and Flight Response as if we were dealing with an ’emergency’.
If this happens, day after day, our bodies to dump out levels of stress hormones over and over again. Unfortunately, a steady dose of something that was supposed to be rare and fleeting can make us physically and emotionally sick.
Bad stress feels overwhelming. It leads to exhaustion, disengagement, conflict, and poor mental health.
Good stress—often called eustress—helps us grow. It comes with a sense of meaning, momentum, and possibility. It pushes us just enough to stretch our skills, sharpen our focus, and pursue our goals with energy.
The difference often lies in how we interpret the stressor and how much support we feel while experiencing it.

The Challenge Response: Helps Us Focus and Perform
Fortunately, our stress response includes two additional types of responses: the Challenge Response and the Tend and Befriend Response. Each of these can be turned on like the Fight and Flight Response and each involves a whole host of neurotransmitters and hormones working in conjunction to help us respond, learn and return to a normal state of being without being ‘damaged’.
The Challenge Response is similar to the Fight and Flight Response, but without the element of fear. During the Challenge Response, our body responds more like it does during physical exercise. Because we aren’t anticipating harm, like in a threat response, our blood vessels stay relaxed. Our heart has a stronger beat, not just faster. Like Fight or Flight response, a Challenge Response gives us energy and helps us perform under pressure. Our adrenaline spikes, our muscles and brain get more fuel, and we get a feel-good chemical surge. The challenge response give us self-confidence, motivates us, gives us energy and helps us to focus and problem solve. It differs from the Fight or Flight response in that we feel focused, but not fearful.
Research shows us that the best way to invoke the Challenge Response is to change the way we think about these challenging situations.
According to psychologist and researcher Alia Crum, there is a three-step process to help switch to a “stress helps” mindset:
- Acknowledge stress when you experience it and notice how it impacts you psychologically and physically.
- Recognize that stress is a response to something you care about. We don’t get stressed over things that we don’t care about.
- Make use of the energy it gives you. Utilize the energy in a productive way.
As a leader, helping your team invoke the Challenge Response during difficult times is critical to creativity, productivity and resiliency.
How leaders can activate the Challenge Response in their teams:
- Frame pressure as purpose. “We’re under a lot of pressure right now and there’s so much coming at us” becomes “This is our opportunity to show what we’re capable of.”
- Break down big goals into manageable steps. People can tolerate more stress when they feel in control and clear about what’s next. Connect to the goals and values of the team and organization. When you take this view, work doesn’t necessarily become less stressful, but it can become more meaningful.
- Celebrate progress, not just results. Acknowledge how far the team has come—even if the final goal hasn’t yet been reached.
- Be a calm, grounded presence. Your ability to stay composed under pressure creates psychological safety and models the Challenge Response in action.
- Protect time to recharge. The Challenge Response uses energy. Build in downtime to replenish it. Encourage short breaks throughout the day, monitor overtime, and normalize stepping away to reset. Sustainable performance depends on consistent recovery.
This response doesn’t erase stress—it channels it into focus, action, and determination.
The Tend and Befriend Response: How Connection Calms the Brain
Stress doesn’t only motivate self-protection through the Fight and Flight Response. It can also unleash the instinct to protect the tribe. In a stressful situation, the Tend and Befriend Response releases oxytocin that helps us to build social bonds, provide motivation, increase intuition and reduce fear. This kind of stress counterbalances our basic survival instinct to avoid harm. It is a biological state engineered to reduce fear and increase hope.
In the workplace, the Tend and Befriend Response can be activated when:
- A teammate offers help during a high-pressure moment
- A leader checks in with compassion during a challenging week
- A team shares mutual vulnerability and feels safe doing so
How Leaders Can Activate the Tend and Befriend Response in Their Teams
- Foster a culture of care. Small actions—asking how someone’s doing, showing empathy when a team member is struggling—build connection. This isn’t just about being nice; it creates the conditions where people feel safe and supported under stress.
- Encourage peer support. Create space for people to lean on each other during demanding times. Encourage buddy systems, collaborative problem-solving, and checking in as a team. Support doesn’t need to come only from leaders—it thrives peer-to-peer.
- Offer opportunities to contribute beyond the self. Working toward shared, meaningful goals helps people feel part of something bigger. Volunteering initiatives, mentoring programs, or team-based projects with a purpose can shift focus from fear to hope.
- Celebrate acts of care and connection. Don’t just reward productivity—highlight the moments when people step up to support one another. These quiet wins are often what keep teams resilient during high-stress periods.
- Build a strong, connected community. People recover faster and perform better when they feel they belong. Team-building events, informal gatherings, and shared rituals strengthen the social bonds that buffer stress and prevent burnout.
By focusing on others, we move out of fear and into courage and hope. People cope better together. Fostering connection helps everyone navigate tough times with more resilience.
Shift the Mindset: Stress Can Be Positive
Psychologist Dr. Alia Crum’s research on stress mindsets shows that when people believe stress can be helpful, they experience fewer negative symptoms—and even improved health and performance outcomes.
This doesn’t mean pretending things aren’t difficult. It means changing the story from “I’m overwhelmed” to “This is hard, but I’m capable,” or “This is stressful, but I’m supported.”
That simple shift in perception can move someone from a reactive state to a responsive one.
Lead the Way: How Leaders Can Shape a Healthier Relationship with Stress
As a leader, you can’t eliminate stress. But you can help your team build a healthier relationship with it.
Practical strategies:
- Talk openly about stress. Don’t hide from the topic. Normalize the conversation and share examples of good stress in action.
- Encourage both individual and collective resilience. Remind people they’re not alone—and that they’re capable of navigating challenges.
- Create a culture of recognition. Celebrating effort and intention helps people stay motivated through pressure.
- Watch for distress. Stress can tip into bad stress quickly. Be attentive to signs like withdrawal, irritability, missed deadlines, or presenteeism.
A Word of Caution: When Good Stress Stops Being Helpful
Not all stress is good, and even good stress has a tipping point. When there’s too much pressure, too little control, and not enough recovery time, it quickly becomes toxic.
Check in often. Ask your team how they’re doing—not just in passing, but in real conversation.
Set boundaries and model them. Encourage breaks, time off, and screen-free evenings.
Make room for rest. No one can perform at their best when they’re running on empty.
Build a Better Stress Culture
Stress is part of life—and part of work. The goal isn’t to eliminate it, but to transform how we relate to it.
When leaders understand the different types of stress responses—and intentionally create the conditions for Challenge and Tend and Befriend to emerge—teams become more resilient, more connected, and more capable.
So next time your team feels the pressure, ask:
- Is this the kind of stress that sharpens our focus?
- Are we supporting each other through it?
- What would make this feel more manageable and meaningful?
Because when stress becomes a tool for growth, not a threat to survival, everyone thrives.
Contact Beverly about hosting a stress management workshop for your teams on how to cope with stress and other stress and mental health training. Discover tips to deal with stress and encourage positive stress management techniques!
If you have some strategies to share – comment on this posting!

Additional Resources:
Social Connections and The Importance Of Workplace Relationships
Celebrations and Social Gatherings
Leaders Effectively Handling Workplace Change
Workplace Wellness: Management Practices That Can Lead To A Toxic Workplace
Increase Productivity And Reduce Stress With The S-O-S Principle
